To Earthlings gazing into space, our solar system appears to be surrounded by billions of stars in the Milky Way. But if we look even further out, would it be possible to find evidence that we were in something even more fantastic, like a black hole?
Black holes are places in the universe where gravity is so strong it distorts the time and space around it; once inside, nothing — not even light — can get out.
In one scenario, a black hole could have swallowed Earth long ago. But if this were to happen, the gravitational pull would be catastrophic, said Gaurav Khanna, a black hole physicist at the University of Rhode Island. As Earth approached the black hole, time would slow. And depending on the size of the black hole, matter could be stretched out into spaghetti-like shapes. Even if the planet survived this “spaghettification,” Earth would be bound for the dense and tiny singularity, where it would be incinerated by the pressure and temperature of an unfathomable gravitational force, Khanna told Live Science.
So we can rule out the possibility that a black hole swallowed Earth at some point in its history; it would have been obliterated in a fraction of a second, Khanna said.
Related: How does a black hole form?
But there’s another way Earth might have ended up in the belly of a black hole: It could have formed there.
“A black hole looks very much like the Big Bang in reverse. … The math looks similar,” Khanna said. While a black hole collapses in on a tiny, highly dense point, the Big Bang exploded out of such a point.
One theory posits that the Big Bang was first the singularity of a black hole in a larger parent universe. The dense center compressed and compressed, “until somehow it blows up and a baby universe is formed within the black hole,” Khanna said.
This theory, known as Schwarzschild cosmology, suggests that our universe now expands within a black hole that is part of a parent universe. In theory, this scenario would mean that universes can exist within universes, like Russian nesting dolls, and that traveling back through a black hole — a likely impossible feat, since light can’t even make the reverse journey — would unlock unknown realms, Khanna said.
However, this theory is unlikely to be proven; nothing can travel back across a black hole’s event horizon.
But if Earth is within a black hole, experts have some estimation of the space chasm’s size. “If we are in a black hole it must be extremely big,” said Scott Field, an associate professor of mathematics at the University of Massachusetts Dartmouth. Earth is not just tucked into a planet-size black hole or even one the size of the solar system. If that were the case, scientists would have noticed, Field told Live Science. There would be observable signatures of the black hole’s spinning. Or, we’d see the subtle distortions caused by extreme gravity — like slowing time and stretching matter — as people moved within the black hole.
If Earth existed in an Earth-size black hole, for instance, people would notice effects of these tidal forces, like spaghettification and slowed time, as they traveled from one spot on the globe to another, said Field, who works on gravitational modeling and simulation, including black hole collisions.
So any black hole Earth called home must be enormous, universe-size and so vast that we can’t travel far enough or fast enough to detect the gravitational distortions, Field said.
From inside a black hole universe, Earthlings “would have no way of knowing there was another parent universe in existence,” Khanna said. We’d be oblivious to it. So finding our universal predecessor would be tough, to say the least. Still, “it would be lovely” if this theory were true, he said.
